This is the aftermath. This is what happens after you drop the spoonful of housemade creamy peanut butter ice cream into the heart of the soufflé ($12). It's hot and cold all at once, a steamy soufflé that not surprisingly tastes exactly like a Reese's peanut butter cup. Dig in and dig quick. The soufflé offers a crisp surface with an airy and delicate interior. It's presented on a long narrow dish, where you'll also be delighted with a pair of chocolate-dipped peanut butter popsicles—the texture akin to a semifreddo—and as well as tiny peanut butter cups. It's large enough for two to share, or one very hungry individual.