We weren't in love with most of our haul from Foragers City Grocer, the new farm-to-everything grocery and prepared food market in Chelsea (there's also an outlet in Brooklyn). But this sandwich struck a deep chord with more than a few of us. When was the last time you couldn't stop taking bites of a chicken sandwich?
The mostly dark meat Rotisserie Chicken ($7.95) is incredibly juicy—and it actually tastes like a chicken that walked around a little. A mild garlic mayo ups the moist and savory factors while predictable but predictably delicious caramelized onions add a pleasant sweetness. The real winner for me was the delicate helping of greens inside, slightly wilted by the heat of the chicken. Note to sandwicheries: more slightly wilted greens, please! Especially if they're slicked with shmaltz.
Foragers City Grocer
All products linked here have been independently selected by our editors. We may earn a commission on purchases, as described in our affiliate policy.