Banana Pudding Ice Cream? Sign me up. Phin & Phebes is a Brooklyn-based ice cream company, and their Banana Whama ($8.99) is made of fresh banana puree and crushed vanilla wafer cookies. It really does taste like banana pudding in frozen form, only fluffier. I ate half the pint with a spoon and made impromptu ice cream sandwiches with the other half. It's a playful ice cream with intense, unmistakeable flavors; it runs on the sweeter side and is not an ice cream for those expecting sophistication. But who can be serious all the time? Also keep an eye out for the Vietnamese Iced Coffee ice cream—this one's made with a blend of chicory and regular coffee, each spoonful trailing off with a cool finish of cardamom on the tongue.
This post may contain links to Amazon or other partners; your purchases via these links can benefit Serious Eats. Read more about our affiliate linking policy.