Pies are a matter of great importance to those of us at Serious Eats—and they're a mighty tough thing to get right. Crusts can be too tough, or not flaky enough, or underbaked or undersalted or they can suffer any of a dozen other ailments. Fillings can be too runny or too gummy or too sweet; once you add in any kind of custard or cream, things get even more unpredictable.
But taste test after taste test, there have been some shops that nearly always emerge as top contenders—making excellent pies no matter the season, no matter the filling. So come meet our favorite 5 pie bakers in New York. (And one honorable mention!)
The Rest of Bakery Week...
The Best Bakeries in New York: American-Style »
The Best Bakeries in New York: French-Style »
My Top 10 Bakery Sweets in NYC »
The Best Baguette in New York »
Where To Get The Best Pies in New York (Our Top 5) »
Good Bread: My Favorite Loaves in New York »
All products linked here have been independently selected by our editors. We may earn a commission on purchases, as described in our affiliate policy.