I haven't been able to stop thinking about these pumpkin pancakes ($14) at The Breslin, so strong is my ambivalence toward them. Wherefore the internal conflict?
Pro: "Pumpkin pancakes with spiced chili pecan butter." How good do those sound? And the pancakes themselves are griddled, amply buttered, with beautifully browned edges.
Con: The pancakes don't taste like pumpkin; the butter doesn't taste spicy.
Pro: The rich candied pecans perched on top.
Con: That orange. Our waitress called it a pumpkin sauce, but seemed unsure; we have our doubts. It reminded Erin of Doritos. It reminded me of red bell pepper, and I wondered whether it wasn't a very muted chili. Either way—fascinating, confusing, but not necessarily appealing.
Pro: The reasonable portion size—an order of restaurant pancakes that I might actually finish. Three little cakes, the diameter of a diner coffee cup, say, and thin as a slip.
Con: Wait—I paid $14 for this?
The Verdict: Give 'em a shot—but only if someone else is picking up the bill.
This post may contain links to Amazon or other partners; your purchases via these links can benefit Serious Eats. Read more about our affiliate linking policy.