What better way to end a stressful work week than with Shake Shack's Pumpkin Pie Oh-My? One big cup of custard with a whole slice of pumpkin homemade pumpkin pie whipped right in. And plenty of whipped cream to top. The menu notes that the pumpkin pie is blended with vanilla custard, but they'll be happy to substitute any custard flavor you like. We had it with the salted caramel custard, though vanilla is the best route, should you been keen on letting pumpkin pie shine though.
All products linked here have been independently selected by our editors. We may earn a commission on purchases, as described in our affiliate policy.