Where To Get Pie For Thanksgiving
There are all sorts of fantastic bakeries in New York where you can pick up pie for your Thanksgiving table. (See last summer's pie finds, our pie honor roll, and our favorite pumpkin pies in NYC for additional reading.) Here's our guide to Serious Eats-approved pie shops all over the city.
View Where to Get Thanksgiving Pie in a larger map
Will be making apple crumb, bourbon pecan, pumpkin, key lime, and banana cream pies for the holiday ($28 for a 9" pie, $52 for 2 9" pies). All orders must be in by November 21.
Hill Country Chicken
Apple pie with cheddar lattice crust, classic pumpkin pie, Maker's Mark bourbon pecan pie, whiskey buttermilk pie, cowboy pie (3" only), sweet potato marshmallow pie, and chocolate chess pies ($3 or $3.50 depending on the flavor for 3" individual pies and $40 or $43 for 11" pies). All orders must be made 48 hours in advance and pies can be picked up between November 19th and November 23rd from 2pm-10pm.
Yura on Madison
Will be making Heritage Brown Sugar pumpkin pie ($25 each), toasted caramel pecan pie ($30 each), and Hudson Valley Apple Orchard ($25 each) pie for the holiday. All orders must be placed by 4:00pm November 20th. Pies will be available for pickup after 2:00pm on November 23rd.
Little Pie Company
Will be making sour cream apple walnut pie, old fashioned apple pie, sugarless apple pie, southern pecan pie, mississippi mud pie, three berry pie, pumpkin pie for the holiday ($30 for a 10" pie, $25 for a 10" pumpkin pie.) Thanksgiving orders must be placed by November 18th. Orders for Thanksgiving Day must be picked up by noon.
Four and Twenty Blackbirds
While they are completely booked for pre-orders, Four and Twenty Blackbirds will offer pies first come first served on November 23rd and 24th (times TBA). Flavors will include salted caramel apple, bittersweet chocolate pecan, brown butter pumpkin, salty honey (prices range from $32-$38).
Greenmarket double-crust apple ($32), sweet potato ($30), 3-1 cream ($40), and pecan ($36) 8" pies for the holiday. Orders must be in by November 22nd at noon.
Sweet Melissa Patisserie
Will be making apple ($32), fresh ginger custard pumpkin ($32), chocolate bourbon pecan ($32), pecan pie ($32), coconut custard ($28), and pear cranberry ($32) 9" pies for the holiday. Orders much be placed by November 21st and pies can be picked up Tuesday, Wednesday or before noon on Thursday.
Will be making white chocolate pecan cake, cranberry and carrot cheesecake, chocolate and hazelnut mousse cake, apple apple apple tart, pear cranberry tart, and a pumpkin tart for the holiday. Prices range from $36-$65 and come in different sizes feeding 6, 8, or 10 people. Order by November 21st and pickup by November 23rd.
Apple, pecan, and pumpkin pies ($36) for the holiday. Pick-ups on November 23rd between 2pm and 8pm.
Dominique Ansel Bakery
Pumpkin pie and praline pie for the holiday ($36 each). Order by November 21st (but they're only making a limited amount so order sooner rather than later) and pick up by noon on Thanksgiving Day.
Will be serving traditional apple, sour cream apple, pear apple caramel crumb, classic pumpkin, and pecan pie. 8" and 10" pies available ranging from $22-$32 for the holiday. Orders must be placed by November 20th for pick-up or delivery on November 23rd.
Apple, pumpkin pecan, key lime, and chocolate peanut butter pies for the holiday (serves 6-8 people). Pumpkin is $28 and all others are $30. Pick-up from 8am to 1pm on Thanksgiving Day.
Apple, pumpkin and pecan pies for the holiday. Pick-up on November 22nd and 23rd or free delivery November 23rd.
'witchcrafr: multiple New York City locations; 212-780-0577; wichcraftnyc.com
Two Little Red Hens
Pumpkin, pecan, dark chocolate pecan, apple, and sweet buttermilk chess pies. All pies come in 6" or 10" for $24 and $32 respectively. They're done taking pre-orders, but will have first-come, first-serve pies available the week of Thanksgiving.
Clinton Street Baking Co.
Will be making pumpkin ($24), organic apple crumb ($24), and maple bourbon pecan ($26) pies. Pies serve 6-8 people. Orders will be taken through November 22nd at noon and must be picked up by 10pm on November 3rd.
Deep dish pumpkin pie ($40). Orders will be taken through November 19th and all pickups are scheduled for Wednesday, November 23rd at 6pm.
The Blue Stove
Pumpkin, bittersweet chocolate mousse, key lime ($24.95), apple, pear cranberry, pear ginger crisp, plum crumble, and molasses pecan pies ($29.31). Refundable deposit on the pie pan is $1. Orders will be taken through the end of the day and must be picked up between November 21st and November 24th at noon.
Will be making apple, pumpkin, and pecan pies ($32). Orders will be taken through November 21st and must be picked up on November 23rd or November 24th.
Pumpkin, chocolate bourbon pecan, and apple pies ($26). Orders will be taken through November 21st and can be picked up until 7pm November 23rd.
Will be making apple ($20-$24), pecan ($20-$24), and pumpkin ($10-$16) pies. Orders will be taken through November 21st and can be picked up through Thanksgiving.