Off-the-Menu Whiskey Cake at Upstate Craft Beer & Oyster Bar


[Photo: Grace Kang]

Lingering over sweet clams on the half shell and a cold Saranac, I settled into the warm buzz of the bar. Maybe it was the crinkle of aluminum foil or a flash of honey brown in the corner of my eye that tipped me off, but suddenly there it was—Wife's Whiskey Cake.

You smell it first--a sweet, smoky whiff of whiskey floating above the slice. Depending on what's around the bar, you'll taste Jameson or maybe Jim Beam, baked into a delicate cake that spends a day in an aluminum foil tomb, marinating in its glaze.


Husband and wife team Shane Covey and Jennifer Gavin opened Upstate a little over a month ago, and have received a warm welcome from the neighborhood for their offering of craft beers, fresh seafood, and a cheery atmosphere. Working from a family recipe, Jennifer usually makes six cakes every week, enough to surprise about 150 guests. Although not technically on the menu, it's often generously offered after a meal—a whiskey sponge to top off the beer belly.

So here's how it goes: order a craft beer and some fresh oysters or clams; endear yourself to the man behind the bar; and you just may find yourself with a lovely sliver of Wife's Whiskey Cake in front of you.


95 First Avenue, NY 10003 (map)

Serious Eats Newsletters

Keep up with our latest recipes, tips, techniques and where to eat!

Comments can take up to a minute to appear - please be patient!

Previewing your comment: