What's Your Favorite Pie Shop In New York?

This has been a good year for pie—in New York and elsewhere. (In fact, we're wondering if pie is the new cupcake.) Of all the pie shops in New York, both new and old, tell us: which is your favorite? Cast your vote »

As always, if your favorite doesn't appear on the list, write it in with a comment.

One moment while we initialize this poll.

You must log in before you can answer the poll. If you don't have an account, you can sign up. It's free and it only takes a moment.

Serious Eats - seriouseats.com